Analysis: Sex offenders and social networking, State v. Packingham – NC Supreme Court

I posted previously about State v. Packingham, in which the North Carolina Supreme Court upheld a state statute prohibiting the use of social networking sites by registered sex offenders. In that post, I promised more analysis. Here it is.

The statute at issue in the decision is N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5:

(a) Offense. — It is unlawful for a sex offender who is registered in accordance with Article 27A of Chapter 14 of the General Statutes to access a commercial social networking Web site where the sex offender knows that the site permits minor children to become members or to create or maintain personal Web pages on the commercial social networking Web site. (b) For the purposes of this section, a “commercial social networking Web site” is an Internet Web site that meets all of the following requirements: (1) Is operated by a person who derives revenue from membership fees, advertising, or other sources related to the operation of the Web site. (2) Facilitates the social introduction between two or more persons for the purposes of friendship, meeting other persons, or information exchanges. (3) Allows users to create Web pages or personal profiles that contain information such as the name or nickname of the user, photographs placed on the personal Web page by the user, other personal information about the user, and links to other personal Web pages on the commercial social networking Web site of friends or associates of the user that may be accessed by other users or visitors to the Web site. (4) Provides users or visitors to the commercial social networking Web site mechanisms to communicate with other users, such as a message board, chat room, electronic mail, or instant messenger. (c) A commercial social networking Web site does not include an Internet Web site that either: (1) Provides only one of the following discrete services: photo-sharing, electronic mail, instant messenger, or chat room or message board platform; or (2) Has as its primary purpose the facilitation of commercial transactions involving goods or services between its members or visitors.

Defendant, a registered sex offender, had a Facebook account. At trial, he was convicted of violating § 14-202.5. The Court of Appeals vacated the conviction, and held that the statute violates the First Amendment and is unconstitutional both on its face and as applied. An as-applied challenge contests whether the statute can be constitutionally applied to a particular defendant, even if the statute is otherwise generally enforceable. A facial challenge, by contrast, maintains that no constitutional applications of the statute exist, prohibiting its enforcement in any context.

A split decision of the state Supreme Court disagreed and reversed the decision, upholding the law and the conviction.

The majority reached a number of conclusions that may be attacked on appeal.

The Facial Challenge

First, the opinion concludes based on Hest Techs., Inc. v. State ex rel. Perdue that the statute prohibits conduct, not speech. 366 N.C. 289, 297, 749 S.E.2d 429, 435 (2012). This sets the standard by which the court reviewed the statute. To uphold a statute that regulates speech, the state must show that the regulation is necessary to serve a “compelling” state interest and that it is “narrowly drawn” to achieve that end. A statute that regulates conduct, however, can have an incidental burden on speech so long as it promotes a “substantial” government interest that would be achieved “less effectively” absent the regulation.

In Hest, the Court looked at regulation of video sweepstakes machines (the kind you see in strip mall “cafes”). There, they concluded that statutes regulating sweepstakes games were, in reality, regulating the underlying sweepstakes (conduct), not the game (speech) that announced the result. The court analogizes this to  N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5, writing that “like the statute in Hest, the essential purpose of section 14-202.5 is to limit conduct, specifically the ability of registered sex offenders to access certain carefully-defined Web sites.”

Fundamentally, this conclusion changed the entire analysis from that point forward. If the Court had concluded, instead, that the statute regulates speech, the much more stringent strict scrutiny standard might have led to a different outcome. The prohibited conduct in Hest was, at its heart, gambling. Here, the prohibited conduct is, at its heart, speech and association. In Hest, the speech (the game) facilitated the conduct (gambling). Here, the conduct (joining a network) facilitates the speech (communicating over the network). The dissent asserts:

This statute completely bars registered sex offenders from communicating with others through many widely utilized commercial networking sites. Therefore, in my view, it primarily targets expressive activity usually protected by the First Amendment.

Next, the opinion concludes that the statute is a content neutral-regulation on conduct. Because of this, the level of scrutiny is lower than it would be if it were a content-based regulation on conduct. Accepting the conclusion that this is a regulation on conduct, not speech, there is little room to debate this second conclusion. The statute does not give any heed to the content of the would-be communication. Interestingly, the trial court found, and no party challenged, that the purpose of the statute was protection of minors from sex offenders. A separate law, which is not content neutral, regulates this conduct specifically. North Carolina G.S. § 14-202.5 criminalizes the solicitation of a child for sex through use of a computer.

In applying the intermediate scrutiny standard, the Court looks to United States v. O’Brien. In O’Brien the defendant claimed the statute forbidding destruction of his Selective Service registration card was unconstitutional as applied because it violated his right to free speech. 391 U.S. 367, 88 S. Ct. 1673, 20 L. Ed. 2d 672 (1968). The U.S. Supreme Court articulated a four part test to apply in situations where the ‘speech’ and ‘nonspeech’ elements are combined in the same course of conduct.

Importantly, the dissent points out that the ban on burning a draft card in O’Brien had a “communicative element.” The dissent suggests that O’Brien should apply only where the restriction targets expressive conduct. Here, the dissent argues, the statute necessarily burdens speech directly, and the O’Brien test is irrelevant. Still, the majority opinion does discuss the factors, and so will I.

The first two factors were not disputed. First, the statute must be within the constitutional power of the Government, which this clearly is. Second, it must further an important or substantial governmental interest. The interest here is protecting kids online from predators, which is indisputably important.

The third factor requires that the governmental interest be unrelated to the suppression of free expression. The Court concluded, in part because of the existence of the separate law prohibiting solicitation (which is related to free expression), that the interest in protecting children was not related to suppression of speech.

The fourth factor is whether incidental restriction on alleged First Amendment freedoms is no greater than is essential to the furtherance of that interest. This factor tests not whether this is the “least restrictive means,” but whether it is “narrowly tailored to serve a significant government interest.” Narrow tailoring, the opinion explains, requires that the government demonstrate that alternative measures that burden substantially less speech would not achieve the government’s interest.

The defendant argued that the statute was not narrowly tailored:

… defendant contends (1) that the statute’s definition of a “commercial social networking Web site” is overbroad, (2) that the statute does not take into account the underlying offense of conviction or the likelihood of recidivism, (3) that the statute does not require criminal intent, (4) that the statute is underinclusive because, inter alia, it applies only to commercial Web sites, (5) that less burdensome laws already exist to protect children from baleful Internet contacts, and (6) that sufficient alternatives allowing communication do not exist.

(numbering added)

The opinion does not address each of these arguments. Instead, it focuses on the definitional arguments in (1) and (4), and the alternatives argument in (6). This is important. It may be that the Court simply felt that the others were not worth considering. Indeed, there is no First Amendment jurisprudence suggesting that under any standard the statute would need to consider recidivism. Still, it would have been nice to see each argument addressed.

The opinion discusses, at some length, the statute’s definition of a social networking website. In short, the statute defines such sites as those that: (1) derive revenue from their operations, (2) facilitate social introduction between persons, (3) allow personal pages or profiles with names, nicknames, photographs, etc., and links to other friends’ or associates’ pages, and (4) provide users mechanisms to communicate with each other. The carve-out excludes from that definition sites that either: (1) provide only one service of: photo-sharing, e-mail, messaging, chat, or boards, or (2) have the primary purpose of commercial transactions.

The criteria and the carve-out, according to the opinion, demonstrate that the legislature “has carefully tailored” the statute. But there have been other First Amendment cases that examined statutes with what appeared at first to be a specific list, with a few carve-outs, targeted at deplorable conduct (think: U.S. v Stevens). Just because the statute appears to be “carefully” tailored, doesn’t mean it was “narrowly” tailored.

The opinion also gives a lot of weight to the knowledge requirement, which says that to convict, the State has to prove that “the sex offender knows that the site permits minor children to become members or to create or maintain personal Web pages on the commercial social networking Web site.” The opinion – essentially – imputes knowledge to users of various sites based on those sites’ terms of service. It also calls out a number of sites that are perfectly acceptable for registered sex offenders to use, because the terms of those sites require users to be 18 (look out Paula Deen Network).

Those of us that draft terms of service know that every.single.user. reads and understands them… The Court writes:

While we leave for another day the question whether a site’s terms of use alone are sufficient as a matter of law to impute knowledge of the site’s limitations on access to a registrant, such terms of use provide specific and pertinent information to a registered sex offender seeking lawful access to the Internet.

After the number of words devoted to discussion of terms of service, and using them to bolster both the argument that the offender has knowledge and that the offender has sufficient alternative channels of communication, this seems like a punt. It may well be that individual persons accused under this law could be shown to have read the terms, seen that users under 18 were or were not allowed, and then decided to proceed to the site. But, this is a facial challenge, not as applied in individual circumstances.

The Court concluded that the statute is narrowly tailored, and therefore facially valid. The dissent, by contrast, concludes that the statute burdens substantially more speech than necessary. Because I don’t think I can say it better than the dissent, I’ve included most of its reasoning here:

First, the statute as written sweeps too broadly regarding who is subject to its prohibitions. As noted, the State’s interest here is in protecting minors from registered sex offenders using the Internet. However, this statute applies to all registered offenders. . . . The statute is not restricted in application only to those whose offenses harmed a minor or in some way involved a computer or the Internet, nor to those who have been shown to be particularly violent, dangerous, or likely to reoffend. This statute therefore groups together, without distinction, offenders whose history and past conduct directly implicate the State’s concerns with those who do not. To the extent the statute does so, it “burden[s] . . . more speech than necessary to achieve the [State’s] interests.” McCullen, ___ U.S. at ___, 134 S. Ct. at 2537.

Second, as written, the statute also sweeps far too broadly regarding the activity it prohibits. The majority asserts that the statute prohibits “registered sex offenders from accessing only those Web sites that allow them the opportunity to gather information about minors.” But in fact, the statute contains no such limitation. . . . I note in particular that the statute’s description of a “personal profile[ ],” and the language “such as” when referring to the information that can appear in such profiles, could bring within the statute’s scope many websites that allow users to register by going through the minimal process of creating a username and adding an email address or telephone number. As a result, this definition clearly includes sites that are normally thought of as “social networking” sites, like Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn, Instagram, Reddit, and MySpace. However, the statute also likely includes sites like Foodnetwork.com, and even news sites like the websites for The New York Times and North Carolina’s own News & Observer. See The News & Observer Terms of Service, http://www.newsobserver.com/customer-service/terms-of-service/ (last visited Oct. 22, 2015) (stating that “[i]f you are under eighteen (18) then you may only use NewsObserver.com with the consent of a parent or legal guardian” but not limiting registration on the site to adults). Most strikingly, the statute may even bar all registered offenders from visiting the sites of Internet giants like Amazon and Google.

In short, however legitimate—even compelling—the State’s interest in protecting children might be, the plausible sweep of the statute as currently written “create[s] a criminal prohibition of alarming breadth,” United States v. Stevens, 559 U.S. 460, 474, 130 S. Ct. 1577, 1588 (2010), and extends well beyond the evils the State seeks to combat. I therefore conclude that N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5 “burden[s] substantially more speech than necessary to achieve the [State’s legitimate] interests,” McCullen, ___ U.S. at ___, 134 S. Ct. at 2537, and cannot survive even the intermediate scrutiny applied to content-neutral restrictions on speech.

(footnote omitted)

The As-Applied Challenge

In discussing the as-applied challenge, the opinion again turns to terms of service:

Because Facebook does not limit users to those over the age of eighteen and otherwise fits the definition of a commercial social networking Web site set out in N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5, defendant is forbidden to access that site unless the statute is unconstitutional as applied to him

So, if a site’s terms of service limit users to those over 18, it falls outside this statute? Even if it otherwise meets the definition and, in fact, is used by minors (perhaps without the permission of the site)?

In considering whether the incidental restriction on the Defendant in this case was “no greater than is essential to further the government’s interest,” the court again concludes the statute is permissible. The defendant was probably not the best person to bring this challenge:

In ascertaining whether the government’s interest in protecting children from registered sex offenders who are lurking on social networking Web sites and gleaning information on potential targets is furthered by prosecution of this defendant, we observe that defendant has the status of a registered sex offender because he was convicted of indecent liberties with a minor, a sex crime against a child falling directly within the purview of section 14-202.5. Officers who searched his home found a signed written notice advising defendant of sites he could not legally access. Defendant set up his Facebook page under an alias, further indicating his awareness that he was indulging in forbidden behavior while simultaneously hiding his identity from investigators and parents.

(emphasis added)

Were the Defendant on the sex offender registry for a crime that did not involve a minor, or any act of coercion or force, had no notice, and used Facebook under his real name, oblivious to the ban, he would have been a better face for this argument. The opinion concludes that the restriction on this Defendant is no greater than essential to further the interest in protecting children from predators.

Overbreadth

A statute is unconstitutionally overbroad if a substantial number of its applications are unconstitutional, judged in relation to the statute’s legitimate sweep. A party raising the challenge must bear the burden of showing from the text of the law, and from the actual facts around the law, that the substantial overbreadth exists.

The opinion references back to its discussion of the definitional portion of the statute in its facial validity discussion. Based on that discussion, the opinion concludes:

Given the reluctance with which courts administer the strong medicine of overbreadth, we conclude section 14-202.5 does not sweep too broadly in preventing registered sex offenders from accessing carefully delineated Web sites where vulnerable youthful users may congregate

In the context of the conclusions the opinion had already reached, it would have been a surprise to see them invalidate for overbreadth. The dissent explains that overbreadth analysis is “very similar to the ‘narrow-tailoring’ inquiry described above: First Amendment overbreadth doctrine requires a court to invalidate a statute that ‘prohibits a substantial amount of protected speech.'” The dissent further explains the analysis, and concludes that the statute is overbroad:

There is, however, one important nuance. Namely, while the Supreme Court of the United States has often invalidated specific applications of statutes under as-applied challenges, that Court has also made clear that First Amendment doctrine specifically permits litigants to make facial challenges based on overbreadth. The Court has even noted that such a challenge is permitted when the challenger’s own conduct would clearly fall within the scope of the statute’s prohibition and the claim is based only on how that statute might apply to the activity of others. In light of this precedent permitting such challenges, and for the reasons noted above, I would hold that the statute at issue here, N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5, is facially overbroad and therefore unconstitutional, regardless of its application in this specific case.

(citations and quotations omitted, emphasis supplied).

I added emphasis to the prior excerpt because I think it is important to remember that, in the context of deciding whether a law that restricts free speech is constitutional, courts are often presented with unsympathetic plaintiffs. Child rapists, animal abusers, cults and others often bring to light the fringes of the law. We need the corner cases, though, or we don’t know the boundaries.

Vagueness

Finally, the opinion discusses the Court of Appeals conclusion that the statute is unconstitutionally vague. Laws must “give the person of ordinary intelligence a reasonable opportunity to know what is prohibited.” This is the opinion’s entire analysis of this point:

The Court of Appeals “assume[d] that persons of ordinary intelligence would likely interpret the statute as prohibiting access to mainstream commercial social networking sites such as Facebook.com.” Packingham, ___ N.C. App. at ___, 748 S.E.2d at 153. Whatever the status of other Web sites, no party disputes that Facebook.com, the site at issue here, falls under N.C.G.S. § 14-202.5’s definition of “commercial social networking Web site.” While an argument may be made that the statutory term “access” could be vague in other contexts, defendant’s logging into his Facebook account and posting a message on his page is unquestionably “accessing” Facebook.com. Defendant’s conduct defeats his vagueness claim

I’m not sure that a single defendant’s conduct should be used to validate the entire statute. I’m not convinced that just because Facebook is clearly prohibited, that a person of ordinary intelligence would understand that The News & Observer’s website is also prohibited.

If the Supreme Court of the United States takes up the issue, it seems likely to me they will strike down the law. Similar provisions in laws in Indiana, Nebraska, Georgia, Utah, California, and Louisiana have been struck down in those states. It’s no secret that the Roberts Court has a strong view of the First Amendment. If this case ever gets to that forum, I think they’re likely to side with Justice Hudson’s dissent and conclude that the majority applied the wrong standard: this is a law regulating speech, not conduct, and should be subject to strict scrutiny.

My wife’s perspective is that all of this is a silly debate; that anyone who is convicted of any sexual act with a minor should receive a summary execution without due process. Then, there would be no need to figure out who should and shouldn’t be allowed to access this-or-that website. But, she didn’t go to law school. “Law school is for softies.”

Brandon J. Huffman

Brandon is the founder of Odin Law and Media. His law practice focuses on digital and interactive media, entertainment, internet related issues and crisis communication. He serves as general counsel to the International Game Developers Association and is an active member of many bar associations and community organizations. He can be reached at brandon at odin law dot com.

Contact Us

Address:

4600 Marriott Drive, Suite 520
Raleigh, NC 27612

Phone:

(919) 813-0090

Email:

info@odinlaw.com

17,739 thoughts on “Analysis: Sex offenders and social networking, State v. Packingham – NC Supreme Court”

  1. What i don’t realize is in reality how you’re now not really a lot
    more neatly-appreciated than you might be right
    now. You’re so intelligent. You recognize therefore considerably in relation to this topic, produced me in my opinion believe it from so many various
    angles. Its like women and men aren’t involved until it is one
    thing to do with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs excellent.
    All the time handle it up!

  2. I just like the valuable info you provide for your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and check once more right here regularly.
    I’m somewhat sure I will be informed a lot of new stuff proper
    right here! Best of luck for the following!

  3. Today, I went to the beach with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4
    year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed
    the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab
    inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back!
    LoL I know this is totally off topic but I had to tell someone!

  4. Hmm it looks like your blog ate my first comment (it
    was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog.
    I too am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing.
    Do you have any tips and hints for newbie blog writers?

    I’d genuinely appreciate it.

  5. Game online masa fashionable memang sangat disukai oleh berbagai
    kalangan karena kemudahan serta keuntungan besarnya. Kemudahan ini bisa dirasakan oleh para pemain judi on-line selama proses perjudian. Mesin slot berputar selama beberapa detik hingga berhenti di tempat yang tepat di server atau di aplikasi Java.
    Dengan modal minimal ini, para penjudi internet online bisa
    meraup untung lebih tinggi jika bisa memenangkan permainan mesin slot.
    Game slot jackpot terbesar menawarkan berbagai jenis recreation dengan berbagai hal dan simbol.
    Melakukan hal itu akan menderita kerugian yang signifikan. Jadi ketika
    jenuh sudah menghampiri, sebaiknya beristirahatlah guna menghindari
    kerugian yang lebih besar. Alasan kedua mengapa perjudian slot web dapat memiliki keuntungan besar bagi para penjudi on-line adalah karena
    peluang bonus yang sangat besar yang ditawarkan permainan. Mengenai pentingnya nilai menang dalam judi on-line, para penjudi judi perlu memahami mengapa hal ini berpotensi
    untuk menarik para penjudi judi online. Alasan mengapa permainan mesin slot lebih menguntungkan dan dapat menghasilkan hasil yang
    menguntungkan ketika Anda berjudi on-line dalam jumlah besar dijelaskan dalam analisis di bawah ini, yang harus dipahami dengan baik oleh penjudi
    on-line.

  6. Normally I do not learn article on blogs, but I would like
    to say that this write-up very pressured me to check out and do it!
    Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very
    great post.

  7. Great goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just too magnificent.
    I actually like what you have acquired here, really like
    what you are stating and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for
    to keep it sensible. I can’t wait to read far more from you.
    This is really a great site.

  8. Thanks a lot for sharing this with all people you actually recognize what you’re speaking approximately!

    Bookmarked. Kindly additionally consult with my web site =).
    We may have a hyperlink change arrangement among us

  9. [url=http://hydroxychloroquinesale.online/]hydroxychloroquine 700[/url] [url=http://zithromaxazithromycin.online/]azithromycin in mexico[/url] [url=http://tadalafilonlinex.com/]discount tadalafil[/url] [url=http://atarax.online/]generic atarax[/url] [url=http://wellbutrin.monster/]wellbutrin nz[/url] [url=http://sildenafilprice.online/]sildenafil generic india[/url] [url=http://finpecia.quest/]finpecia online[/url] [url=http://effexor.monster/]effexor canadian pharmacy[/url] [url=http://viagracanadian.online/]viagra best buy india[/url] [url=http://sildenafilpills.quest/]4 sildenafil[/url]

  10. [url=http://kamagra.monster/]kamagra oral jelly online pharmacy[/url] [url=http://cialis20mg.quest/]canadian pharmacy cialis 5 mg[/url] [url=http://citalopram.monster/]citalopram mexico[/url] [url=http://cheapestviagra.online/]buy cheap viagra india[/url] [url=http://cialiscost.online/]cialis pharmacy cost[/url] [url=http://fluoxetine.quest/]fluoxetine 40mg capsules[/url] [url=http://acyclovir.monster/]acyclovir best price[/url] [url=http://zithromaxazithromycin.online/]can i buy azithromycin online[/url] [url=http://wellbutrin.monster/]bupropion price comparison[/url] [url=http://lasixfurosemide.com/]lasix buy online[/url]

  11. [url=http://sildenafilcitrate100.online/]buy sildenafil 50mg uk[/url] [url=http://tadalafilatabs.online/]tadalafil 20 coupon[/url] [url=http://synthroid.monster/]synthroid 0.0125 25mcg[/url] [url=http://cialisxrx.online/]cialis in mexico online[/url] [url=http://cialiscanadianpharmacy.online/]brand name cialis for sale[/url]

  12. [url=http://disulfiram.quest/]antabuse tablets buy[/url] [url=http://modafinilprovigil.online/]modafinil online uk paypal[/url] [url=http://cialis5mg.quest/]buy online cialis 5mg[/url] [url=http://viagractabs.online/]cheap viagra soft tabs[/url] [url=http://sildenafilytab.online/]sildenafil 50 mg tablet coupon[/url] [url=http://cialisttabs.online/]ciallis[/url] [url=http://genericsildenafilcitrate.quest/]sildenafil online sale[/url] [url=http://lasixfurosemide.com/]furosemide 60 mg[/url] [url=http://tadalafilgenericonline.com/]tadalafil 5mg buy[/url] [url=http://effexor.monster/]effexor medicine[/url]

  13. [url=http://tadalafiltabsonline.com/]cheap tadalafil no prescription[/url] [url=http://escitalopram.quest/]buy generic lexapro online[/url] [url=http://atarax.online/]atarax buy[/url] [url=http://citalopram.monster/]citalopram 10mg order[/url] [url=http://vardenafillevitra.online/]where to buy levitra[/url]

  14. [url=http://wheretobuycialis.quest/]generic cialis uk[/url] [url=http://flagyl.quest/]flagyl medicine[/url] [url=http://hydroxychloroquinepills.com/]quineprox 500[/url] [url=http://vardenafillevitra.online/]levitra from usa[/url] [url=http://sildenafilcitrate100.online/]sildenafil in singapore[/url] [url=http://cialis5mg.quest/]cial[/url] [url=http://amoxil.quest/]amoxil 250 mg tablets[/url] [url=http://ivermectinatab.com/]stromectol online pharmacy[/url] [url=http://wellbutrin.monster/]wellbutrin brand name coupon[/url] [url=http://propecia.quest/]how much is propecia nz[/url]

  15. [url=http://tadalafilfdb.com/]tadalafil 7mg[/url] [url=http://cialisgk.com/]generic cialis 20 mg safe website[/url] [url=http://100mgviagra.quest/]where can i buy genuine viagra[/url] [url=http://paxil.monster/]paxil for panic attacks[/url] [url=http://atarax.today/]atarax mexico[/url] [url=http://buyivermectinpills.quest/]stromectol pill for humans[/url] [url=http://sildenafilcitrategn.com/]sildenafil price comparison uk[/url] [url=http://zoloft.live/]zoloft over the counter[/url] [url=http://propecia.today/]buy cheap generic propecia[/url] [url=http://ivermectinpills.monster/]stromectol tablet 3 mg[/url]

  16. [url=http://cialis20.quest/]canadian cialis cheap[/url] [url=http://lasix.monster/]otc lasix[/url] [url=http://trazodonepills.live/]trazodone 150[/url] [url=http://viagratbl.com/]viagra online order in india[/url] [url=http://cialisict.com/]generic cialis discount[/url]

  17. [url=http://genericsildenafilpills.com/]cost of sildenafil 20 mg[/url] [url=http://buytadalafilwhere.com/]tadalafil free shipping[/url] [url=http://viagrazpill.com/]canadian drug pharmacy viagra[/url] [url=http://antabuse.today/]disulfiram tablets[/url] [url=http://sildenafilcitrategn.com/]buy sildenafil 50mg[/url] [url=http://ivermectinztab.online/]ivermectin pills human[/url] [url=http://zovirax.today/]order zovirax cream online[/url] [url=http://ivermectintablets.monster/]ivermectin virus[/url] [url=http://ivermectinpills.monster/]stromectol cost[/url] [url=http://atarax.live/]where to get atarax[/url]

  18. [url=http://tadalafilonlinesale.com/]tadalafil 5mg[/url] [url=http://propecia.today/]propecia women[/url] [url=http://100mgviagra.quest/]buy female viagra online india[/url] [url=http://paxiltabs.world/]paxil 15 mg[/url] [url=http://zoloft.live/]zoloft 50 mg tablet[/url] [url=http://cymbalta.quest/]how much is cymbalta 30 mg[/url] [url=http://zoloftforsale.live/]buy sertraline online[/url] [url=http://viagrammc.com/]viagra brand name generic drug[/url] [url=http://cialismtablets.com/]cost of cialis 20mg in canada[/url] [url=http://tadalafilfdb.com/]tadalafil cost in mexico[/url]

  19. [url=http://amoxil.monster/]over the counter amoxicillin 500mg[/url] [url=http://synthroid.today/]synthroid online no prescription[/url] [url=http://vlviagra.com/]lowest price viagra 100mg[/url] [url=http://ivermectinpills.monster/]price of stromectol[/url] [url=http://cialisseven.com/]best price for daily cialis[/url] [url=http://bestviagrageneric.com/]generic viagra cheapest[/url] [url=http://sildenafilcrp.com/]order cheapest sildenafil[/url] [url=http://xsildenafilpills.com/]sildenafil price comparison[/url] [url=http://lexapro.live/]lexapro 10[/url] [url=http://buygenericcialisonline.quest/]cialis cheapest price uk[/url]

  20. [url=http://ivermectinpills.monster/]stromectol cream[/url] [url=http://sildenafilcrp.com/]sildenafil buy online usa[/url] [url=http://ivermectinpill.monster/]buy ivermectin canada[/url] [url=http://zoloftforsale.live/]zoloft rx[/url] [url=http://buycialisbuy.com/]cialis 5mg daily for sale[/url] [url=http://buyviagraonlinepharmacy.com/]30 mg viagra[/url] [url=http://ussildenafil.com/]sildenafil 100mg gel[/url] [url=http://xsildenafilpills.com/]sildenafil gel 100 mg[/url] [url=http://trazodonepills.live/]trazodone 25[/url] [url=http://amoxil.monster/]amoxicillin usa[/url]

  21. [url=http://viagrammc.com/]average cost of viagra 2018[/url] [url=http://ivermectinpill.monster/]ivermectin 500ml[/url] [url=http://ivermectinxl.online/]ivermectin 3mg tablets[/url] [url=http://buycitratesildenafil.com/]buy sildenafil 20 mg online[/url] [url=http://malegrapills.quest/]generic malegra[/url]

  22. Today, I went to the beachfront with my children. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter
    and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear and screamed.
    There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back!

    LoL I know this is totally off topic but I had to tell someone!

  23. [url=https://buyinggenericcialistablet.monster/]cialis super active plus[/url] [url=https://viagramedicationonlinedrugstore.monster/]viagra best price[/url] [url=https://genericviagradrugforsale.quest/]sildenafil 20 mg tablet coupon[/url] [url=https://onlinecialis40mgnoprescription.monster/]canada rx cialis[/url] [url=https://buybestviagrapills.quest/]viagra tablet[/url] [url=https://cialispillssale.monster/]15mg cialis[/url] [url=https://cheapcialis5mgprice.quest/]cialis 10mg india[/url] [url=https://cialispillsonlinedrugstore.monster/]cheap cialis overnight[/url] [url=https://cheapcialismedicationforsale.quest/]cialis soft 20 mg[/url] [url=https://onlinecialis20pill.quest/]over the counter cialis canada[/url]

  24. [url=http://onlineviagra50mgpills.monster/]cheapest price for viagra 100mg[/url] [url=http://cialispillforsale.quest/]cialis usa price[/url] [url=http://cialismedicineforsale.quest/]price for cialis[/url] [url=http://cheapviagrapillbuy.monster/]viagra sales[/url] [url=http://cialis10mgcost.quest/]cialis online pharmacy usa[/url]

  25. [url=http://ordercialismedicationwithnorx.quest/]canadian generic cialis online[/url] [url=http://onlinecialisforsale.quest/]cheap tadalafil[/url] [url=http://cheapviagratabsbuyonline.monster/]can you buy generic viagra in canada[/url] [url=http://viagradrugrx.monster/]viagra online price comparison[/url] [url=http://cialispillforsale.quest/]cialis 2[/url] [url=http://buycialistabsprescription.monster/]buy cialis europe[/url] [url=http://bestviagratabletsonline.quest/]us viagra prices[/url] [url=http://bestviagra150mgnoprescription.quest/]cheap viagra 100mg canada[/url] [url=http://cialis10mgcost.quest/]order cialis online cheap[/url] [url=http://genericcialistabletswithoutrx.monster/]canadian generic cialis pharmacy[/url]

  26. Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am
    encountering difficulties with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I am unable to subscribe to it.
    Is there anybody else having the same RSS problems? Anyone who knows the solution can you kindly respond?

    Thanks!!

  27. [url=https://sildenafilbcitrate.com/]sildenafil 25 mg prices[/url] [url=https://acyclovir.quest/]acyclovir pill[/url] [url=https://ivermectinitabs.com/]stromectol 3mg[/url] [url=https://hpviagra.com/]viagra pills for sale canada[/url] [url=https://buyduloxetine.com/]generic cymbalta buy[/url]

  28. [url=http://hlviagra.com/]sildenafil citrate vs viagra[/url] [url=http://lasix.today/]lasix india[/url] [url=http://accutaneisotretinoin.online/]generic accutane[/url] [url=http://mrcialis.com/]viagra cialis[/url] [url=http://kamagratabs.monster/]erectile dysfunction kamagra oral gel[/url] [url=http://sildenafilaac.com/]sildenafil 100g[/url] [url=http://zoloftforsale.online/]where can i get zoloft[/url] [url=http://cialisbed.com/]cialis pills india[/url] [url=http://buyzestoretic.com/]buy zestoretic online[/url] [url=http://tadalafilonlinediscount.com/]tadalafil 20mg mexico[/url]

  29. [url=https://buyduloxetine.com/]cymbalta price australia[/url] [url=https://chloroquine.live/]chloroquine 1mg[/url] [url=https://dexamethasone.live/]dexamethasone 2mg tablets[/url] [url=https://zoloftforsale.online/]zoloft for sale[/url] [url=https://paxil.live/]paroxetine 12.5 mg price in india[/url] [url=https://amoxicillin.quest/]best amoxicillin brand[/url] [url=https://retina.quest/]buy retin a online mexico[/url] [url=https://sildenafilyeah.com/]sildenafil 5mg price[/url] [url=https://cialisbed.com/]cialis 20mg uk[/url] [url=https://cialisubuy.com/]rx cialis canada[/url]

  30. [url=https://ivermectinitabs.com/]where to get ivermectin[/url] [url=https://allopurinol.quest/]medication allopurinol[/url] [url=https://zithromax.monster/]generic zithromax over the counter[/url] [url=https://celexa.monster/]15 mg celexa[/url] [url=https://augmentin.monster/]augmentin 875 otc[/url]

  31. [url=https://ciali.quest/]cost of cialis[/url] [url=https://cialtabs.quest/]cialis coupon canada[/url] [url=https://buycildenafil.quest/]sildenafil india price[/url] [url=https://cealis.quest/]where to buy generic cialis online canada[/url] [url=https://viagprescription.quest/]viagra canadian pharmacy generic[/url]

  32. [url=https://buysildanafil.quest/]best price for sildenafil 100 mg[/url] [url=https://cial.quest/]reputable onlinecompanies that sell cialis[/url] [url=https://buyviagonline.quest/]where can you buy female viagra[/url] [url=https://cialigeneric.quest/]cialis 10mg cost[/url] [url=https://buytadalfil.quest/]generic tadalafil coupon[/url] [url=https://sildenafll.quest/]sildenafil rx[/url] [url=https://genericviaga.quest/]viagra generic canada price[/url] [url=https://cialiprice.quest/]cialis 600 mg[/url] [url=https://onlineviaga.quest/]viagra 100mg online uk[/url] [url=https://cialscanada.quest/]compare cialis prices[/url]

  33. [url=https://onlineviaga.quest/]viagra tablet cost in india[/url] [url=https://viagronline.quest/]best price for genuine viagra[/url] [url=https://viiagracanada.quest/]viagra canada prescription[/url] [url=https://viagara.quest/]canadian viagra paypal[/url] [url=https://tadalafi.quest/]tadalafil 6mg[/url] [url=https://taladafil.quest/]rx pharmacy online tadalafil[/url] [url=https://viagacanada.quest/]viagra for sale online usa[/url] [url=https://sidenafilcitratevigra.quest/]viagra in mexico cost[/url] [url=https://vigra.quest/]sildenafil viagra 100mg[/url] [url=https://ciais.quest/]cialis.com[/url]

  34. whoah this weblog is great i like studying your articles.
    Stay up the great work! You recognize, lots of
    persons are looking around for this info, you can aid them greatly.

  35. [url=https://ivermectingtab.com/]stromectol for head lice[/url] [url=https://neurontin.live/]neurontin cost in canada[/url] [url=https://indocin.today/]indocin brand name[/url] [url=https://bactrim.live/]buy bactrim online uk[/url] [url=https://ivermectingtab.online/]ivermectin medicine[/url] [url=https://cytotec.quest/]cytotec prescription[/url] [url=https://strattera.live/]strattera discount coupon[/url] [url=https://lopressor.today/]lopressor 50 mg price[/url] [url=https://diflucan.today/]where can i buy diflucan 1[/url] [url=https://ivermectinitab.com/]stromectol tablets[/url]

  36. I’m now not sure the place you’re getting your
    information, but good topic. I needs to spend some time finding out much more or working out more.
    Thank you for excellent info I used to be on the lookout for this info for my mission.

  37. I’ve been browsing on-line greater than 3 hours today, but I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours.
    It is beautiful worth sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all web owners and bloggers made good content material as you probably did,
    the web shall be a lot more helpful than ever before.

  38. I know this web site presents quality dependent content and other information, is there any other web page which offers these kinds of information in quality?

  39. En ucuz ve kaliteli siteden uygun fyatlara satın alabilmek için takip2018 in bütün faydalarından hemen faydalanabilirsiniz, Türk takipçi paketleri 1000 adet
    takipçiden başlayarak 100bin takipçiye kadar alabilirsiniz.

    100bin takipçiyi sadece 12 saat içerisinde profilinize yükleyebiliyorlar.

    Takipçi Satın Al sitesinden takipçi almak için hemen takip2018.com a giderek alın.

  40. Sizinle büyük bir sır paylaşıyorum hemen profilimde bulunan siteye girerek takipçi sayısınızı kimsenin anlamayacağı şekilde yükseltebililrsiniz.
    Takipçi sayısı arttırmak için yukarıdaki linke tıklayın ve satışlarınıza büyük oranda katkı payı sağlayın.

  41. [url=https://cials.quest/]cialis generic canadian[/url] [url=https://cialitabs.quest/]ed chewables[/url] [url=https://buygenericcialionline.quest/]cialis 5mg tablets australia[/url] [url=https://buytadalfil.quest/]tadalafil 20mg no prescription[/url] [url=https://genericviaga.quest/]uk viagra[/url]

  42. [url=https://cephalexin.live/]keflex caps 500mg[/url] [url=https://abilify.today/]price of abilify 30 mg[/url] [url=https://malegrapills.online/]buy malegra online[/url] [url=https://glucophagemetformin.online/]metformin cost canada[/url] [url=https://ivermectinvtab.online/]stromectol 12mg[/url] [url=https://permethrin.online/]elimite otc prescription[/url] [url=https://valtrex.today/]how to buy valtrex online[/url] [url=https://glucophagemetformin.com/]metformin hydrochloride[/url] [url=https://diflucan.today/]diflucan prescription cost[/url] [url=https://avodart.quest/]generic brand of avodart[/url]

  43. Undeniably believe that that you said. Your favourite justification seemed to be at
    the net the simplest thing to bear in mind of. I say to you, I definitely get irked
    even as folks think about worries that they plainly don’t recognise about.
    You managed to hit the nail upon the highest as neatly as defined out the
    whole thing with no need side effect , other folks can take a signal.

    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  44. Check 1this website[/url] to see how to get free diamonds in cooking fever

    gh45kkm
    The game is a lot more fun when you have as many diamonds as you want.If you love phone games like this you need to check out this website

  45. [url=https://mysildenafilshop.com/]where can i purchase sildenafil[/url] [url=https://prednisone.live/]buy prednisone from canada[/url] [url=https://motrin.monster/]600 mg motrin otc[/url] [url=https://buypriligy.online/]priligy price nz[/url] [url=https://viagranpills.com/]viagra brand name online[/url] [url=https://zithromax.today/]zithromax 500mg over the counter[/url] [url=https://sildenafilpillsforsale.com/]sildenafil 100mg australia[/url] [url=https://aurogratabs.monster/]aurogra 100 mg[/url] [url=https://cialiszpills.com/]india cialis online[/url] [url=https://arimidex.monster/]1mg arimidex[/url]

  46. [url=https://viagracpro.com/]order real viagra online[/url] [url=https://sildenafilgenerictab.com/]sildenafil generic india[/url] [url=https://gabapentin.monster/]buy gabapentin online without prescription[/url] [url=https://ecsildenafil.com/]sildenafil 20 mg tablet cost[/url] [url=https://modafinil.today/]provigil best price[/url] [url=https://cialislx.com/]online pharmacy in canada cialis[/url] [url=https://ivermectinatabs.online/]buy ivermectin online[/url] [url=https://cialisbtp.com/]cheapest 20 mg cialis[/url] [url=https://ivermectinotab.com/]ivermectin 1 cream 45gm[/url] [url=https://sildenafilrtab.com/]sildenafil 20 mg online[/url]

  47. Excellent site you have here but I was curious if you
    knew of any community forums that cover the same topics
    talked about in this article? I’d really love to be a
    part of online community where I can get feedback from other
    knowledgeable people that share the same interest.
    If you have any suggestions, please let me know.
    Appreciate it!

  48. [url=https://modafinil.today/]provigil no prescription[/url] [url=https://ivermectinvtabs.com/]ivermectin cream 5%[/url] [url=https://cialisbtp.com/]cialis 20mg pills[/url] [url=https://mysildenafilshop.com/]cheap sildenafil 50mg[/url] [url=https://diviagra.com/]viagra 50 mg price in usa[/url] [url=https://wellbutrinbupropion.online/]purchase wellbutrin[/url] [url=https://arimidex.live/]arimidex[/url] [url=https://kamagratabs.online/]kamagra soft tabs 100mg[/url] [url=https://cialisptabs.com/]buy cialis daily[/url] [url=https://generictadalafilorder.com/]price tadalafil 20mg[/url]

  49. Hi, I do think this is a great site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I will return yet again since
    i have book marked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to
    change, may you be rich and continue to help others.

  50. I was suggested this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody
    else know such detailed about my trouble. You are wonderful!
    Thanks!

  51. I do not know whether it’s just me or if perhaps everybody else experiencing issues with your
    blog. It appears as though some of the text within your content are running off the screen. Can somebody else
    please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening
    to them as well? This may be a issue with my web browser because
    I’ve had this happen before. Thank you

  52. [url=https://ivermectinatabs.online/]stromectol 12mg online[/url] [url=https://ivermectinotab.com/]where can i buy oral ivermectin[/url] [url=https://tadalafillx.com/]tadalafil in india online[/url] [url=https://viagrabuyz.com/]real viagra canada[/url] [url=https://provigil.live/]buy generic provigil[/url] [url=https://cialisurem.com/]otc cialis pills[/url] [url=https://trazodonepills.online/]trazodone 250 mg[/url] [url=https://atarax.monster/]atarax 10mg tablet[/url] [url=https://prednisone.live/]prednisone 20mg[/url] [url=https://nrtadalafil.com/]generic tadalafil 40mg[/url]

  53. PC Toplama Robotu

    PC Toplama Robotu bir diğer adıyla PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile hayalinizdeki
    bilgisayara ulaşmak çok daha kolay. PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile herhangi bir bilgiye ihtiyaç duymadan istediğiniz bilgisayarı dakikalar hatta saniyeler içerisinde toplamak mümkün. İşlemci seçiminize göre
    anakartların otomatik olarak listelendiğini üstelik hangi işlemciye hangi anakart
    uyumlu derdi olmadan listelendiğini düşünün, bu çok büyük bir kolaylık sağlayacaktır.

    Bu sayede, herhangi bilgiye muhtaç olmadan kolay şekilde bilgisayarınızı toplayabilirsiniz.

    Kullanıcılar her daim kaliteli bilgisayar toplamak isterler.
    En ucuz bilgisayarı toplamak isteyenler genelde yüksek performansıda göz
    ardı etmezler. Hem ucuz hemde oyun oynayabilecekleri bilgisayar toplamak isteyenlerin en çok tercih ettiği bu
    uygulamanın yanında hazır sistemlerde vardır.

    Toptanbilgisayar ekibinin oluşturduğu hazır sistem bilgisayarlar ilede dilerseniz pc toplama robotunu kullanmadan bilgisayarınızı anında satın alabilir ve
    kargo işlemlerini başlatabilirsiniz. PC Toplama Sihirbazında en çok
    sorulan soruların başında toplanan bilgisayar bir bütün halinde mi yoksa parçalar halinde
    mi geleceğidir, demonte olarak veya diğer şekilde gönderim seçenekleri mevcuttur.
    Ayrıca şunu belirtmekte de fayda var. Bilgisayar toplama sihirbazını kullanırken teklif oluşturarak topladığınız parçaları bir liste halinde görüntüleyebilir ve bu listeyi arkadaşlarınız veya
    müşterileriniz ile paylaşabilirsiniz.

    Sizde ucuza hızlı ve güvenilir şekilde bilgisayar toplamak istiyorsanız hemen pc toplama robotunu kullanmaya başlayın! Ödüllü PC toplama sihirbazı ile başka neler yapabileceğinizide anlatmadan bu
    yazıyı sonlandırmak istemeyiz. PC Toplama Robotu başka değişle
    PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile ürünleri rahatlıkla karşılaştırabilir veya ürün özelliklerine
    doğrudan erişim sağlayabilirsiniz. Robot sayesinde hangi oyunların veya programların çalışacağınıda önceden kestirebilir ve hayal kırıklığına uğramanın önünü kesebilirsiniz.
    En çok merak edilenlerin başında pc toplama robotunu kullanmak ücretsiz mi sorusu gelmektedir.
    Pc Toplama robotu ücretsizdir. Ücretsiz PC Toplama Sihirbazını kullanmak için neyi bekliyorsunuz?

    PC Toplama Robotu

  54. PC Toplama Robotu

    PC Toplama Robotu bir diğer adıyla PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile hayalinizdeki
    bilgisayara ulaşmak çok daha kolay. PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile herhangi bir bilgiye ihtiyaç duymadan istediğiniz bilgisayarı dakikalar hatta saniyeler içerisinde toplamak mümkün. İşlemci seçiminize göre
    anakartların otomatik olarak listelendiğini üstelik hangi işlemciye hangi anakart
    uyumlu derdi olmadan listelendiğini düşünün, bu çok büyük bir kolaylık sağlayacaktır

    Bu sayede, herhangi bilgiye muhtaç olmadan kolay şekilde bilgisayarınızı toplayabilirsiniz.

    Kullanıcılar her daim kaliteli bilgisayar toplamak isterler.
    En ucuz bilgisayarı toplamak isteyenler genelde yüksek performansıda göz
    ardı etmezler. Hem ucuz hemde oyun oynayabilecekleri bilgisayar toplamak isteyenlerin en çok tercih ettiği bu
    uygulamanın yanında hazır sistemlerde vardır.

    Toptanbilgisayar ekibinin oluşturduğu hazır sistem bilgisayarlar ilede dilerseniz pc toplama robotunu kullanmadan bilgisayarınızı anında satın alabilir ve
    kargo işlemlerini başlatabilirsiniz. PC Toplama Sihirbazında en çok
    sorulan soruların başında toplanan bilgisayar bir bütün halinde mi yoksa parçalar halinde
    mi geleceğidir, demonte olarak veya diğer şekilde gönderim seçenekleri mevcuttur.
    Ayrıca şunu belirtmekte de fayda var. Bilgisayar toplama sihirbazını kullanırken teklif oluşturarak topladığınız parçaları bir liste halinde görüntüleyebilir ve bu listeyi arkadaşlarınız veya
    müşterileriniz ile paylaşabilirsiniz.

    Sizde ucuza hızlı ve güvenilir şekilde bilgisayar toplamak istiyorsanız hemen pc toplama robotunu kullanmaya başlayın! Ödüllü PC toplama sihirbazı ile başka neler yapabileceğinizide anlatmadan bu
    yazıyı sonlandırmak istemeyiz. PC Toplama Robotu başka değişle
    PC Toplama Sihirbazı ile ürünleri rahatlıkla karşılaştırabilir veya ürün özelliklerine
    doğrudan erişim sağlayabilirsiniz. Robot sayesinde hangi oyunların veya programların çalışacağınıda önceden kestirebilir ve hayal kırıklığına uğramanın önünü kesebilirsiniz.
    En çok merak edilenlerin başında pc toplama robotunu kullanmak ücretsiz mi sorusu gelmektedir.
    Pc Toplama robotu ücretsizdir. Ücretsiz PC Toplama Sihirbazını kullanmak için neyi bekliyorsunuz?

    PC Toplama Robotu

  55. Dripping with cum that slides all the way down to cover her knockers, Queenlin can’t stop smiling in satisfaction. petite nude ass After taking a proper pussy pounding on her hands and knees, Nikole climbs back on top so she can ride Jason like her own non-public steed.

  56. I’m really loving the theme/design of your web site.

    Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility problems?
    A number of my blog visitors have complained about my blog not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Opera.
    Do you have any tips to help fix this issue?

  57. [url=http://doxycycline.today/]buy generic doxycycline[/url] [url=http://zithromax.live/]azithromycin 250 mg over the counter[/url] [url=http://buyzithromax.quest/]azithromycin without rx[/url] [url=http://clomid.live/]how can i get clomid[/url] [url=http://tadalafilatab.com/]price of tadalafil[/url]