Assistant county attorney properly terminated for election to city council – Fourth Circuit

Loftus v. Bobzien. Bobzien, the Fairfax, Virginia, County Attorney, fired Loftus, an assistant county attorney, after she was elected to Fairfax City Council. The termination was “solely because she had been elected to the City Council.”

Loftus sued claiming the termination violated her First Amendment rights, as well as Virginia Statute and a local Fairfax County ordinance. The district court dismissed the complaint, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed.

Prior to her run, Loftus had been informed by Bobzien that election to the City Council could create conflicts because the County had continued interactions and contracts with the City. When she announced her candidacy, he sent her a letter again expressing the same and an additional concern about imputed conflicts of interest for the other attorneys in the office under the state bar’s rules of professional ethics. In that letter, he informed her that if she won, she would be terminated.

Loftus called the state bar’s ethics hotline, and Bobzien requested an informal advisory opinion from the state bars Standing Committee on ethics. They received conflicting information, with the hotline saying it was not per se unethical to serve in both capacities, and the Standing Committee referring back to prior ethics opinions (which Bobzien had referenced in his letter to Loftus) and declining to provide further comment.

After taking office, she was terminated.

Loftus brought two First Amendment arguments to the district court. First, she argued that she has an “unfettered and inherent First Amendment right to hold public office.” Second, she argues that she should prevail in a balancing test of her First Amendment rights and the concerns of her employer.

The Fourth Circuit begins its analysis by pointing out that they have never recognized a First Amendment right to hold public office. Without reaching a conclusion on that question, they point out that 70 years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed that a government-employer may circumscribe the rights of its employees to engage in political activity and has since consistently approved restrictions on various activities, including holding public office.

In such cases, courts defer to the legislative body or government entity charged with making determinations about the overlap between public employment and elected office. The opinion recognizes the Letter Carriers test in which a restriction is upheld based on four principles: the restriction

  1. helped ensure the unbiased administration of the law,
  2. avoided the appearance of impropriety,
  3. preserved meritbased government employment and prevented corruption, and
  4. ensured the independence of all government employees.

The opinion then looks at a litany of precedents from around the country and from the Second, Fifth, Seventh and Eighth Circuits concluding that various restrictions or prohibitions public employees on holding elected office were upheld. The Fourth Circuit is not swayed by her arguments that those precedents are distinguishable because she is working in a different municipality or because the office she was elected to is a nonpartisan office.

With respect to the balancing argument, the Fourth Circuit concludes that the balance of interest weighs in favor of Bobzien’s decision to terminate:

On one side of the equation is the extent to which Bobzien’s decision to terminate Loftus’ employment infringed on any assumed First Amendment right she might have to hold public office. We conclude any infringement was minimal, as Bobzien’s decision to terminate Loftus only after she was elected to a position on the City Council regulated her speech with a limited touch, if at all. Nowhere does Loftus plausibly allege that she was prevented from speaking on issues pertinent to her campaign or any other issues of public import. Nor does she allege she was prevented from conducting her campaign for City Council. Loftus’ complaint alleges no restraint on her First Amendment rights except the fact her employment was terminated “solely because she had been elected to the City Council.”

On the other side of the equation is Bobzien’s interest, which also is Fairfax County’s interest, in the efficient operation of the Fairfax County Attorney’s Office. As a general matter, the County was not required to sit idly by as one of its employee lawyers took on additional “duties or allegiances to another locality or political constituency whose interests are or could be adverse” to its own. The possibility that Loftus’ duties as a member of the City Council would conflict with her duties as an assistant county attorney was more than mere speculation, given the history and reality of the relationship between the two municipalities. Because Loftus’ membership on the City Council potentially was inconsistent with her position as an assistant county attorney, Bobzien reasonably apprehended serious inefficiencies arising from that arrangement.

In particular, Bobzien believed that Loftus’ membership on the City Council and position as an assistant county attorney would create a far-reaching and intractable conflict of interest, not only for Loftus but also for the entire Fairfax County Attorney’s Office. Prior to terminating Loftus’ employment, Bobzien contacted the Standing Committee, which pointed him to LEOs 1718 and 1763. Both of those LEOs strongly suggested that Loftus’ continued employment as an assistant county attorney and her membership on the City Council would create an incurable conflict of interest, one which would prohibit any attorney in the Fairfax County Attorney’s Office from representing the County in matters, adverse or otherwise, with the City.

Loftus’ own correspondence with Ethics Counsel confirms the reasonableness of Bobzien’s position.

The opinion also evaluates her claims under Virginia law and a local ordinance. The court declines to read into each provision a private right of action that does not exist in the plain terms of the law.

In short: if you are a public employee, and you run for public office, be ready to walk away from your current job to take the office. It’s another barrier to entry for many who might otherwise be drawn to public office, yes, but in this case the potential for conflict seems pretty apparent.

Brandon J. Huffman

Brandon is the founder of Odin Law and Media. His law practice focuses on transactions and video games, digital media, entertainment and internet related issues. He serves as general counsel to the International Game Developers Association and is an active member of many bar associations and community organizations. He can be reached at brandon at odin law dot com.

Contact Us

Address:

4600 Marriott Drive, Suite 520
Raleigh, NC 27612

Phone:

(919) 813-0090

Email:

info@odinlaw.com

7,401 thoughts on “Assistant county attorney properly terminated for election to city council – Fourth Circuit”

  1. мотель горизонт рамзай официальный сайт пансионаты николаевка крым
    отель кипарис дубки отель лагерь восток туапсе
    отдых крым сатера ерино санаторий официальный сайт отзывы

  2. санаторий черного моря мини хостел санкт петербург
    гостиницы тамань краснодарский край гостиница в энгельсе недорого на сутки адлер отдых с питанием и бассейном
    дом отдыха вороново вольгинский санаторий владимирская область цены где лечат болезнь бехтерева

  3. отели крыма все включено с бассейном абхазия в начале сентября
    гранд отель в геленджике цены отдых для пенсионеров в подмосковье отель incity лобня
    аквалоо отзывы аквапарк кисловодск мечта официальный сайт семикаракорск казачья пристань

  4. загородный клуб касабланка сольилецкий санаторий
    туапсе транспортник отель шелфорт санкт петербург официальный сайт вода северное сияние
    отель беларусь красная поляна официальный голубая волна алушта отзывы по соц путевкам санаторий бфо анапа официальный сайт

  5. новочеремушкинская 66 ассоль гостиница
    геленджик голубая лагуна санатории рф официальный сайт сан шахтер ессентуки официальный
    зудек гостевой дом анастасия туапсе гидромассаж в санатории

  6. геленджик пансионат приветливый берег официальный сайт хостел верхотурье
    курорты средней полосы россии отдых в крыму 2020 цены отель русь сочи официальный сайт
    гостиница ассоль геленджик отель море алушта официальный сайт как добраться до небуга на поезде

  7. санаторий в сухуми с лечением екатерининский адлер
    пансионат абхазии гостиница камин ижевск гостиницы в белокурихе недорого
    домина престиж санкт петербург отель метрополь геленджик цены санаторий горный горячий ключ цены

  8. гостиница уют в воронеже похудение в санатории подмосковья
    скидки в санатории кисловодск санатории 2021 порт весьегонск официальный
    отель шексна гостиница олимпия лангепас отель замок адлер

  9. интурист официальный сайт поиск тура отель белый грифон
    гостиница пилигрим кемерово пансионат победа горячий ключ санаторий предгорье кавказа официальный сайт
    белокуриха карта санаториев и отелей санаторно оздоровительный комплекс фрегат санаторий синдика нальчик

  10. лучшие санатории пятигорска к визит отель
    анапа отдых семьей марриотт на павелецкой москва пос курортное
    отдых в воронежской области с питанием санатории для астматиков и аллергиков в россии летний отдых в абхазии

  11. санаторий источник ессентуки цены апарт отель владыкино
    курорты белоруссии цены грегори клаб хутор труд уют сергиев посад
    перлина прикарпатья трускавец официальный сайт дом отдыха солнечный сочи гостиница арт ульяновск на московском шоссе

  12. старая руза санаторий кардиологические санатории ленинградской области
    ай даниль крым официальный сайт гостиница колыма магадан базилион цены
    евпатория администрация официальный сайт арт отель пермь бювет минеральной воды

  13. smart hotel neo иваново белокуриха благодать официальный сайт
    эко отель пушкинские горы отель с бассейном в москве расписание казань васильево
    оздоровительный санаторий для детей северное сияние саки гостиница на тульской москва

  14. цены гостиниц в москве пансионаты средней полосы россии
    отель пицунда в пицунде отзывы гранд афон отель абхазия официальный сайт пицунда отдых 2022 цены на берегу моря
    домбай горнолыжный курорт отели белокуриха центросоюз санатории под петербургом

  15. жемчужина сочи официальный сайт цены красная талка геленджик телефон ресепшн
    лагерь сосновый бор ярославская область санаторий чайка могилев песчаная бухта севастополь
    москоу холидей феодосия золотой пляж отдых vertical aparthotel

  16. златоуст хостел кисловодск радоновые ванны
    новостройки в абхазии информация о музее в пятигорске про лермонтова уролог евпатория
    о санатории летние туры на море санатории сочи с лечением 2021

  17. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Everything information about medication.
    https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol ireland
    Everything information about medication. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  18. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
    https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol where to buy
    Everything about medicine. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.

  19. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. safe and effective drugs are available.
    ivermectin drug
    What side effects can this medication cause? Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  20. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
    buy stromectol canada
    Read information now. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.

  21. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Drugs information sheet.
    lisinopril 40
    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.

  22. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
    https://tadalafil1st.com/# buy cialis brand
    Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Read information now.

  23. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Read now.
    https://tadalafil1st.com/# use paypal to buy cialis
    Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.

  24. I have read your article carefully and I agree with you very much. This has provided a great help for my thesis writing, and I will seriously improve it. However, I don’t know much about a certain place. Can you help me?