What kinds of Easter eggs can get a game into legal trouble?

Easter eggs have been around in video games for decades. For the longest time I thought the first Easter egg in video games dated back to 1979 in Atari’s Adventure, where Warren Robinett coded his name inside the game. Turns out there was an Easter egg even earlier than that! 1973’s Moonlander features a McDonald’s reference if you lower the lander just right.

Easter eggs are cool because they give developers an opportunity to have some fun while rewarding curious players for exploring every corner of their games. Perhaps unsurprising, however, Easter eggs aren’t always as amusing to lawyers, publishers or intellectual property owners.

Here are a few reasons why easter eggs can be risky for video game developers.

Copyright: An homage isn’t always fair use

One of the most common types of Easter eggs is paying homage to other creative works, a hat tip in the world of games. Developers might recreate a famous scene from a movie, or hide a familiar character in the background, or even reference a popular meme.

Here’s where copyright law comes in: reproducing protected elements of another work, such as original artwork, music, dialogue or characters, without permission may constitute infringement (even if it’s a small reference.) Developers might assume these references are “fair use,” but remember: fair use is a defense. It is a fact-specific legal analysis that can only really be determined by a judge and jury. In other words, if someone decides to sue a developer over an Easter egg that infringes copyright, the developer won’t be able to see if “fair use” applies until after time and money have been spent litigating the issue.

To be clear, referencing another work is not automatically infringement either. The rightsholder might love the reference! But the rightsholder needs to know and weigh the risks.

Trademark: Looking for logos in all the wrong places

Like the McDonald’s reference in Lunar Lander, recognizable brands can make for some entertaining Easter eggs. However, amusing as it may be, using another company’s trademarks can also raise legal liability.

Trademark law generally protects against non-authorized uses that are likely to cause confusion about the source, sponsorship or affiliation of goods and services. For example, an Easter egg that makes players believe a popular brand officially sponsored or collaborated on a game may raise the ire of the brand owner.

So why do some brands appear in video games? The mere appearance of a trademark in a video game does not automatically constitute infringement. Licensing agreements may permit the use, trademarks may appear in ways that don’t create confusion, and certain uses may even receive First Amendment protection in the United States (though, again, as with a fair use defense, it’s often risky).

As with any joke, reference, or homage: context matters. A passing reference to a fictional company with a similar name presents different considerations than prominently featuring another company’s actual logo in a way that suggests an official partnership.

Rights of Publicity: Who is she…?

Sometimes developers include recognizable celebrities, athletes, musicians or other real people in their games. Enter: rights-of-publicity.

Using someone’s name, likeness, voice or other identifying characteristics can infringe that person’s rights of publicity. Rights of publicity generally protect certain individuals against unauthorized exploitation of their identities. For example, an Easter egg featuring a popular celebrity’s face, voice or other identifying characteristics may raise rights-of-publicity concerns, even if the developer doesn’t use the celebrity’s actual name.

However, not every reference to a real person is unlawful. Whether a particular use is permissible depends on factors such as the nature of the depiction, the context in which it appears, applicable state law, and potential First Amendment protections. Also, the fact that a reference is intended as a joke or tribute doesn’t automatically make it so—the celebrity may have differing ideas on whether the reference was funny or not. One last note: the scope of these rights vary from state-to-state, so understanding where and how liability arises, especially in a digital context, can be complicated.

Your Publisher Might Not Find It Funny (or Cute)

Beyond the intellectual property concerns outlined above, Easter eggs can create contractual problems, too, especially when a game is being developed under a publishing agreement.

Publishing agreements often contain provisions addressing intellectual property ownership, third-party rights, content approvals and compliance with applicable laws. Depending on the agreement, an Easter egg gone wrong can see the developer facing indemnification liability, breached contractual warranties and the costs associated with correcting the issue. Even without a lawsuit, an unauthorized Easter egg could require a patch, delay a release, cause some very awkward conversations between the developer and publisher, or all of the above and more.

Tracking and disclosing Easter eggs is especially important when development teams have multiple people contributing assets and content. An Easter egg added by one enthusiastic team member could become a problem for the entire studio.

So, Are Easter Eggs Really That Bad?

No! People generally love Easter eggs in games! They’ve been around for decades and they aren’t going anywhere anytime soon. Easter eggs are part of what makes video games fun.

To reduce risk, however, developers should consider whether their Easter eggs incorporate third-party intellectual property, reference recognizable individuals, contain potentially problematic material or conflict with contractual obligations. Creating original references, obtaining permissions where appropriate and including Easter eggs in the normal content review process (ideally with a legal professional in the mix) can help reduce unnecessary risk.

Odin Law & Media works with video game developers, publishers, and studios on intellectual property, licensing, publishing agreements and other legal issues throughout game development.

Veda Cruz

Veda Cruz is a video game lawyer, educator, and indie developer. She represents studios and creators across the games industry and teaches video game law and business at the University of Miami. She can be reached at veda at odin law dot com.

Contact Us

Address:

4208 Six Forks Rd.
STE 1000
Raleigh, NC 27609

Phone:

(919) 813-0090

Email:

[email protected]